PREsentation
| | Practical 實用價值 a) Objective Clarity b) Encourage Application of Knowledge | Reflective 反思深刻 a) Knowledgable b) Enable profound reflection with debriefing | Engaging 引人入勝 a) Public Speaking Skills b) Highly interactive | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Poor (1) | a) The course's objective is unclear and lacks focus. The skills or ideas introduced are not applicable to real-world scenarios and offer no clear benefits.
Improvement needed: Define clear objectives and connect course content to real-world applications.
b) There is no effort from the instructor to engage students in behavioural changes.
Improvement needed: Incorporate activities that encourage students to apply what they've learned. | a) The instructor lacks knowledge about the subject, and the content delivered lacks depth.
Improvement needed: Enhance subject matter expertise and deliver more complex content.
b) There is minimal facilitation for reflection and understanding of oneself and the world. Debriefing skills such as questioning, reflection, and group dynamics are barely utilised.
Improvement needed: Increase the use of debriefing skills to promote reflection. | Poor: a) The instructor lacks public speaking skills and fails to captivate attention.
Improvement needed: Develop public speaking skills to better engage students.
b) The course lacks interactive components like group discussions, games, and psychological assessments, and students seem disengaged.
Improvement needed: Incorporate interactive elements to improve student engagement. | | Mixed (2) | a) The course's objective is somewhat clear but lacks consistency. The skills or ideas presented have limited applicability in real-world scenarios.
Improvement needed: Consistently align content with course objectives and improve connections to real-world applications.
b) There is some effort from the instructor to engage students in behavioural changes, but it's inconsistently applied.
Improvement needed: Figure out what’s hindering the students to change; Reflect on the practicality and clarity of the methods you use to facilitate change. | a) The instructor has some knowledge of the subject, and some content delivered goes beyond the obvious.
Improvement needed: Further deepen subject matter expertise and provide more insightful content.
b) There is occasional facilitation for reflection and understanding of oneself and the world, but it's inconsistent. Debriefing skills such as questioning and reflection are used sporadically.
Improvement needed: Consistently promote reflection and effectively utilise debriefing skills. | a) The instructor has some public speaking skills, but could improve in areas like tone and pacing.
Improvement needed: Identify which areas of public speaking needs improvement and work on them.
b) The course includes some interactive components like group discussions, games, and psychological assessments, but their deployment is inconsistent, and students' immersion in the course could be improved.
Improvement needed: Consistently implement interactive elements and improve strategies to immerse students in the course. | | Good (3) | a) The course's objective is mostly clear, and the course has a focus. The skills and ideas presented are applicable in real-world scenarios with some clear benefits.
For instance, a course on communication skills may include real-world examples of successful negotiation tactics.
b) The instructor engages students in behavioural changes but could improve the effectiveness of their engagement methods.
For instance, the instructor could use more real-world scenarios and role plays to encourage students to apply the skills learned. | a) The instructor is knowledgeable about the subject, and the content delivered often goes beyond the obvious.
For example, a psychology instructor may provide insights and details around a psychology theory.
b) There is consistent facilitation for reflection and understanding of oneself and the world. Debriefing skills such as questioning, reflection are regularly used with good awareness of the group dynamics, but there's room for more effective utilisation.
For instance, after group activities, there may be consistent debriefing sessions where students share their insights and reflections. | a) The instructor shows good public speaking skills, with clear tone and pacing. The course uses a variety of presentation skills, like storytelling and analogies.
For example, the instructor may use personal stories or relevant analogies to explain complex concepts.
b) The course includes interactive components like group discussions, games, and psychological assessments. However, there's room for improving students' immersion in the course and the instructor's skills in leading the exercises.
For instance, the instruction of the interactive exercises is clear and the process of facilitation is smooth, yet the instructor did not lead the students to proactively reflect upon their experiences. | | Excellent(4) | a) The course demonstrates a clear intention in achieving the desired purpose, and is focused throughout. Each step of the course links to the ultimate objective. The skills and ideas covered in the course are highly applicable in real-world scenarios and have clear benefits when applied.
For instance, a course on personal growth may have each lesson or activity contribute to a final personal development plan.
b) Moreover, the instructor skillfully engages the students to try out these skills and successfully brings about behavioural change.
For example, students may demonstrate behavioural changes in their final projects or reflections. | a) The instructor is extremely knowledgeable about the subject and delivers knowledge to students beyond the obvious, mindfully adjusting to the students' status and level.
For example, a psychology instructor may can quickly analysis students’ novel question and offer extra perspectives.
b) The course facilitates deep reflection and changes how students view themselves and the world in a profound and positive way. The instructor skilfully uses debriefing skills such as questioning, reflection and the way that these skills are deployed is flexible and shows in-depth understanding of the group dynamic.
For instance, students may share their personal growth and changes in perspectives in their final course reflections that reflect a substantial change. | a) The instructor is an excellent public speaker that naturally captivates attention. The tone and pacing are clear and well-modulated. The course uses a wide range of presentation skills, such as stories and analogies.
For instance, the instructor may seamlessly weave personal stories or relevant analogies into the lessons.
b) The course includes well-thought-out interactive components like group discussions, games, and psychological assessments. The instructor shows excellent skills in leading the exercises, and students seem fully immersed in the course experience.
For example, students may actively participate in the interactive components and provide positive feedback on their experiences. |
Practicality (實用價值)
a
b.
Reflectiveness (反思深刻)
a
b.